No rewards - what am I doing wrong?

I’ve been mining for 4 or 5 days on mainnet. Originally I setup a node on my Windows 10 machine, I never saw any rewards after a day, and once I got my docker node up and running I switched to that, which seems like its working aside from it stopping for no reason yesterday and having to restart. Here are my stats when I do a lookup, what am I doing wrong?

Annotation%202019-07-11%20080922

1 Like

Isn’t the average reward only like once every 5 days anyway? And if the network’s growing, I assume that number goes up. You want to hold fire and just see what happens. Some get lucky and a few back to back, others wait for a while before anything happens.

1 Like

That is helpful, there isn’t much info like that available so that at least level sets my expectations a bit. Is there anything I can do to increase my relayMessageCount?

I believe that’s more based around your latency than anything. Besides faster connection, I don’t think you can increase it. At the moment there are many people simply running dozens of nodes, if not more. Simply playing the numbers game. I’d be tempted to say to think of running a node as helping the system as a whole, which eventually adds value, over a profitable endeavour at the moment. That said, hoarding NKN now and selling at a higher price is profitable, so every little helps.

For testing purpose, I have a small number of nodes that I run and paid by myself. And you can see that in the last 8 days running, the mining reward is drastically different among mining nodes but the average is very close to global average.

    • DO-1: 11.4
    • DO-2: 0
    • DO-3: 68.49
    • DO-4: 0
    • DO-5: 0
    • DO-6: 11.4
    • DO-7: 34.2
    • DO-8: 79.9
    • AWS-1: 11.4
    • AWS-2: 0
    • GCP-1: 0

So the average yield per node per day is about 2.46

(11.4+68.49+11.4+34.2+79.9+11.4)/11/8

If we calculate the global network average it is about 2.46

(3600*24/20)*11.4/20000

So my personal fleet of 11 nodes across 3 cloud platforms average to almost exactly the global average. But the node to node variation is huge:

  • The worst nodes: 5 nodes out of 11 yield zero mining reward over 8 days
  • The best node: DO-3 yield 79.9 NKN or 7 blocks over 8 days
1 Like

@zbruceli, would you be willing to share information about the regions in which the nodes have been deployed?

8 of my DO nodes are in Frankfort, Germany. while the last one is in Toronto, CA.
My AWS nodes are in Oregon
My GCP nodes are in US Central (I guess Iowa?)

Thanks for sharing :slight_smile:

I just passed 48 hours and haven’t seen anything yet. I might throw a node up on DO just to compare the two. Though, the responses in here pretty much tell me what to expect.

An update after running the nodes for about 11days on mainnet v1.0.4 (except The RPi3 or Raspberry Pi 3, which is more like 7 days):

12%20PM
37%20PM

As you can see, more RelayMessageCount in general leads to more mining rewards. For example DO-1click8, which relayed the largest amount of messages (60,326) and get most mining rewards (17 blocks). RPi3 relayed the second smallest amount of messages (4,789) over 7 days, and yields zero mining reward.

But over this period, there are still lots of variations. For example, AWS-OR2 relayed the smallest amount of messages (4,765) but actually got 4 mining rewards which is about average.

The morale of the story? My sampling size is just too small compared to the total amount of nodes, and my time frame is not that long.

1 Like

Thank you for sharing your numbers …

But I have one doubt …

You only show those nodes because they are the ones that have a reward? (except one)
Or do you have more nodes?
I ask this, because in your case + 90% of your nodes have rewards …
Mine, around 31% … (Counting since the last update to v1.0.4-beta-1-g2c717)
I have a + -250 nodes and only 75-80 have any rewards (none 17 rewards;))
It is true that that 30% averages with the production numbers of the Community (2,46), but my 30% is very far from your 90%

Regards!

That’s all my nodes, total 15. I don’t have any other nodes.

1 Like